Note: This post may contain affiliate links which means if you click on a link and purchase an item, we will receive an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you.
“College students are stuck on traditional, “safe” paths and end up with jobs they don’t like so they can buy shit they don’t need to impress people they don’t like.” –Nat Eliason
My main issue with college isn’t with the education itself. It’s with the concept that people are better off with a college degree and $60,000-250,000 in debt. Taking on a huge amount of debt greatly reduces your options in life and your ability to take risks.
A recent study showed that three-fourths of colleges have a higher 20-year annualized ROI than the S&P 500. This means that from a financial standpoint, you’re objectively better off investing your money in the stock market than going to a bottom 3/4ths college.
Obviously, if you have a full scholarship or if you’re pursuing a career that requires college (i.e., doctor, lawyer, teacher), this is a different conversation.
Table of Contents
Is college worth the time and money?
“If you want to be an entrepreneur, skip the school and go straight for execution.” –Neil Patel
Whether college is worth it comes down to the core philosophical belief of whether you’re optimizing to be an owner or an employee in both your career and in life.
If you’re optimizing to spend your career as an employee and live within society’s normal confines, then college is the safe and standard option.
But if you aren’t sure that you want to be an employee, you need to think long and hard about the cost/benefit of paying hundreds of thousands of dollars to go to college.
If you plan to live life on your terms, run businesses, and/or pursue your passions, college is likely a waste of time and money.
Why?
The only benefit you gain from college that you can’t re-create on your own (at minimal cost) is a credibility stamp.
You can re-create everything about the college experience (except the credibility stamp):
Whatever you could possibly want to learn: the information exists on the internet for you to consume. Want to become a professional painter? There are hundreds of thousands of hours of tutorials and demos online. Literally anything that you want to learn, you can learn from the best in the world in that category. See Masterclass, YouTube, Udemy, Coursera, etc.
Times have changed, education has changed, but universities have not changed. My most valuable college lessons came from listening to successful people speak on YouTube about building businesses.
2. Exposes you to lots of new people and helps you network
This is something that you can easily re-create cheaply by backpacking around the world and by working hard to network and meet new people.
Many of the most interesting people that I’ve met have been a result of cold emailing them. This isn’t something that costs any money.
3. Buys you time to find your path in life
Why spend $15k-60k per year to buy yourself time when you could get paid to learn new things and figure things out by building a business?
What To Do Instead of College:
The best way to re-create the social aspects of college is by backpacking.
2. Embrace the journey of self-learning
Learning how to use the internet to teach yourself new things is one of the most important skills you can learn. In an unstructured learning environment, becoming good at this is an absolute must.
3. Pursue your passions, start a business, or learn in-demand skills (i.e. engineering, design, etc.)
Starting an online business is easier than ever before. And there are many online schools where you can learn a new skill and get a $60k-100k job within 6-12 months.
If I were going back in time, I would’ve picked up an in-demand skill, got a job, and skipped college.
Final Thoughts:
“Our system of elite education manufactures young people who are smart and talented and driven, yes, but also anxious, timid, and lost, with little intellectual curiosity and a stunted sense of purpose: trapped in a bubble of privilege, heading meekly in the same direction, great at what they’re doing but with no idea why they’re doing it.” –William Deresiewicz
I don’t plan to send my kids to college because it’s a poor financial investment and because the most exciting part of life is chasing your passions and living your life on your terms. Both of which are frequently blocked by the burden of college debt.
Definitely would hold true for a lot of people. And yet, it’s been so ingrained for high schoolers (and their parents) that going to college is the only path to success. For many who need a specific degree to get a specific job they do need a college degree. Ie, you can’t be a teacher without a teaching degree. For those that choose not to go to college they could be limiting their career choices down the road. But as you say there are so many opportunities to be an entrepreneur for those that are motivated. Many of your points in this blog post are reasons why I don’t support the government using our tax money to provide free college education for all. Would love to hear your thoughts on this as to me it seems like a natural progression of the idea. (If college is a waste of money than the government shouldn’t waste our taxes on paying for it.)
You made some good points here! You’re right about specific degrees needed for specific jobs and that there isn’t really an alternative path if that’s your goal.
Whether tax money should go towards colleges is a much deeper question and something I admittedly haven’t thought about that much and don’t have an immediate comment on. You have me thinking :).